Growling

by Cherrie Pierson
(Kincheole Michigan)

Growels at our smaller dogs.gets jealous at them being on my lap

Comments for Growling

Average Rating starstarstarstarstar

Click here to add your own comments

Nov 08, 2017
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
growling
by: Anonymous

Yep, if he see's you as alpha then he wants to be 2nd in command. My St. Bernard does the same with my 7 1/2 month Pyrenees/ Anatolian mix. I do not allow it, Cody stays on 1 side and keno gets the other side. As my dogs are not allowed on furniture I am on the floor and each gets a side and when Cody lifts his lip he is corrected. Keno has to be 3rd in line as Cody has been 2nd for awhile and is his senior. I do not push Cody aside but I definitely let him know I am alpha and run the show. Very normal behavior.

Nov 09, 2017
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Growling
by: Donna

Never 'correct' a dog when they growl. They are telling you they don't like something. It is a warning. If you don't allow them to growl, they go right for the bite.

As for humans being alpha, this is an excerpt from Dr. Ian Dunbar's (veterinarian behaviourist) article in Dog Star Daily (http://www.dogstardaily.com/blogs/lets-just-be-humans-training-dogs):

To cavalierly and simplistically summarize considerably complicated canid social behavior as "a dominance hierarchy with an alpha dog dictator", is an insult to both dogs and wolves, and, advertises a complete misunderstanding of their most sophisticated social structure.

Whereas misunderstandings are understandable and excusable, we have to stop at people imposing the weirdness of their misunderstandings upon others.

To extrapolate a misunderstanding of wolf and dog behavior to dog training by citing slippery, phantom concepts of "dominance" and "alpha" as excuses to physically bully dogs is both unfounded and quite distasteful.

If you don’t know how to train the dog, it’s OK. No biggie. Come and learn how. But please don’t just assume that it’s all the dog’s fault. Don’t reflexively blame your dog. Don’t call your dog names.

Don’t assume that your dog is wolfy, or contemplating world domination. And above all, don’t make alpha-dominant excuses to make your dog’s life a misery by psychologically or physically bullying him/her under the guise of dog training. Instead, as a human being with a supposedly superior-functioning brain, give your dog the education that he/she deserves. As humans, we don’t walk on our knuckles when teaching children to read.

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Great Pyrenees Questions.









Breaking News

  1. Pregnant - At what age?

    Jan 20, 18 08:42 AM

    A what age can female Pyrenees give birth?

    Read More

  2. Coats are long

    Jan 19, 18 03:28 PM

    we are on a waiting list and pups will soon be born,we like the long haired pry. is there a way to tell.Mom has short and dad is long!THANKS for any and

    Read More

  3. Newfoundland Dog - Clarification

    Jan 17, 18 01:48 PM

    Is this a white Newfoundland? No, it is a Great Pyrenees. But, scientists say that Newfoundland dna can be traced back to Great Pyrenees dna. So some believe

    Read More

  4. Mannie - Courtesy Posting for Helping Paws Rescue

    Jan 11, 18 06:39 PM

    Meet Mannie Mannie is a 3 year old 110lb Great Pyrenees. He is a gigantic teddy bear. He is super sweet. He loves everyone he meets. Like any good Pyr,

    Read More

  5. Aggression - Two Females

    Jan 10, 18 05:39 AM

    Our 2 year old great Pyrenees, both unfixed females, have suddenly started fighting. The younger one by 3 months has started attacking the other one when

    Read More

  6. Fish - Do they store fish?

    Jan 08, 18 06:53 PM

    Do Great Pyernees store fish? Because I saw my great Pyrenees eating a catfish in winter and our pond is frozen now so she could not get in the pond right

    Read More

  7. Bear

    Jan 04, 18 08:48 AM

    This is beautiful Bear. He is a Pyr mix (or, a big whitish fluffy). He came to us from a shelter so we do not have much information on him. He is about

    Read More

  8. Jack

    Jan 04, 18 08:46 AM

    *ADOPTION PENDING* We believe Jack to be between 6-8 years old. He is a Maremma mix and weighs approximately 95 lbs. Jack came to us from a small farm

    Read More