To spay or not to spay?

by Joyce
(Connecticut USA)

First, this is such an amazing club and such a great resource for all things Pyrenees. Thank you!

Charlette has turned two years old and we are discussing whether or not to spay her. We would only do it for health reasons as we can keep her safe from pregnancy.

Our vet feels we should absolutely spay her to reduce her risk of certain types of cancers. Our breeder feels we should wait until she is at least five years old, if we spay her at all. Charlette's bloodline is clean and disease free.

We would love your advice.

Thank you!

Comments for To spay or not to spay?

Average Rating starstarstarstarstar

Click here to add your own comments

Sep 27, 2020
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Spay or not to spay
by: Donna

It's a pretty personal decision. I, personally, always spay at two if I have a puppy. I cannot guarantee she will never wander or an intact canine will not get at her. I've not had any health issues with my dogs.

When I adopt they are already spayed/neutered to ensure no further pups are produced and rightfully so.

If you can guarantee your bitch will never come in contact with another intact male, you could leave her. However, being Pyrs, they love to hang outside. You'd be amazed at how animals can do their thing through and over fences.

Here is something I pulled out of Dr. Becker's article below:

My second choice is to sterilize without desexing. This means performing a procedure that will prevent pregnancy while sparing the testes or ovaries so they can continue to produce hormones essential for the dog's health and well-being.

And, Dr. Becker's article:

Spay or Neuter

I hope this helps.

Sep 28, 2020
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Thank you, Donna!
by: Joyce

Hi Donna,

Thank you so much for your very thoughtful response and introducing me to Dr. Becker. I truly appreciate it.

Do you know if intact Great Pyrenees are prone to/have high rates of uterine or ovarian cancer or pyometra? I have not been able to find any breed-specific information on this topic.

Thank you again!

Joyce

Oct 07, 2020
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Intact
by: Donna

I don't think it's breed specific. I think if cancer occurs it could be other things involved.

I've only had spayed and neutered dogs with no side effects of which I am aware. I have heard discussion on both sides about dogs getting cancer if they are spayed/neutered or left intact.

Here is an article by Dr. Will Falconer for you to consider, as well:

Spay/Neuter - Dr. Will Falconer

There is also this article:

To spay or not to spay - Dogs Naturally

Oct 19, 2020
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Thank you!
by: Joyce

Thanks Donna!
Appreciate your thoughtful response.
All my best, Joyce

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Great Pyrenees Questions.









Breaking News

  1. Sky

    Sep 26, 22 08:46 AM

    *On Hold* DOB: June 17, 2021 Location: Dashwood, Ontario Kids: Yes Dogs: Yes (we always recommend the opposite sex in the home as not all dogs of the

    Read More

  2. Sophie

    Sep 13, 22 01:43 PM

    *ADOPTED* DOB: Guesstimate 2012 - 10-years-old Located in Erin, ON Sweet Sophie was surrendered to a shelter after her owner died. We brought her into

    Read More

  3. Kari

    Sep 03, 22 05:55 PM

    DOB: June 15, 2020 Location: Erin, Ontario Kari needs a new family who will make him a part of their lives, and be committed to him to continue to make

    Read More

  4. Kevin

    Aug 26, 22 07:46 PM

    Kevin is a 9-year-old mix with maybe Retriever in him.We are still learning more about him. This is what we have so far: We think he has not had much

    Read More

  5. Courtesy Posting - Peter

    Aug 25, 22 10:04 AM

    *ADOPTED* Location: London area *Pyr-experienced home only* This handsome boy is 3-years-old. He was found as a stray. Peter will do great as a working

    Read More

  6. Courtesy Posting - Edison

    Aug 17, 22 07:58 AM

    *ADOPTED* *Courtesy Posting* Located in Orillia, Ontario. Easy-going Edison is looking for a new home! Edison (Eddie) is a friendly 2 year old (approx.)

    Read More

  7. Tina

    Jul 24, 22 12:30 PM

    D.O.B. July 12, 2017 Located in Erin, Ontario This sweetheart Great Pyr is looking for an experienced Pyr person. She will go to a home with children

    Read More

  8. Lady

    Jul 24, 22 11:53 AM

    *ADOPTED* 10-years-old Located in Erin, ON Sweet Lady whom we brought in from the North last year is looking for a new home. Her owner, sadly, passed

    Read More