Neuter or Not

I know with other breeds, particularly those more prone to aggressive behavior, this procedure supposedly helps to make them less likely to act out. However, I understand Great Pyrs are a relatively calm breed. Would this procedure be of any benefit? I am not big on altering in general so I thought I would ask. I do not plan on showing our pup.

Thanks!

Comments for Neuter or Not

Average Rating starstarstarstarstar

Click here to add your own comments

Jul 03, 2020
Rating
starstarstarstarstar 		Neutering
by: Donna

A well-bred Pyr will be socialized and handled by many people with the breeder and then by you. He should not become aggressive because he is intact. However, he may not tolerate other intact males.

Negative training can make a Pyr aggressive.

If you can guarantee your Pyr will not impregnate a female, you can leave him intact. Make sure you have secure fencing. Know that males/females are very innovative when the need arises.

So many irresponsible people leave their dogs intact with no secure fencing. Then, when females are in heat, they go wandering. Sadly, some are hit by cars, poisoned or shot by farmers. The ones who do make it home after being picked up by humane societies, have left a few impregnated females.

It does come down to being responsible.
Jul 04, 2020
Rating
starstarstarstarstar 		neuter & spay
by: Anonymous

It would be interesting to know why your parameters for altering your dog, or not, are 'aggression' and 'acting out'. Leaving him intact shouldn't make him anything.
However, if intact, he will be single-minded in his purpose if there is a female in heat of any breed persuasion within 50 miles or so. He will wander. That's what leaving him in a natural state will do. Leaving him intact and expecting him to be a happy, balanced dog in your fenced-in yard, will only feel right to you. As an intact male he will always, always be on the hunt for an opportunity to breed.
All I can say is, do what is best for HIM as your pet companion. We are in our elder years. In our youth, spaying and neutering was not done. We dealt with the consequences. I can tell you truthfully, the neutered males we have had lately (4) are happier, healthier and perfectly content to lay beside our rocking chairs and be with us.
They do not miss their 'you know whats' a bit.
The bonus for us is that they are perfect gentlemen on the walk and approach other dogs only as a new play pal potential. And we do not worry about them 'acting out' to use your words, when we take them with us anywhere!
Its your choice. Just please choose for your dog and not for yourself.

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Great Pyrenees Questions.

Show / Hide
CLICK TO FOSTER A PYR
PLEASE CLICK THE IMAGE

Breaking News

RSS

  1. Courtesy Post - Remi

    Oct 17, 25 11:09 AM

    *ADOPTED* Remi (Retriever/Pyr cross) D.o.B: Sept. 30, 2023 Location: Between Owen Sound and Port Elgin (Tara, ON) Remi was given up because of health

    Read More

  2. Bo

    Oct 10, 25 04:03 PM

    *Bo is staying with his foster.* DOB: late Sept 2023 (don’t know for sure) rescued Dec 2023 Location: Norwood Ontario Name: Bo Single dwelling home

    Read More

  3. Courtesy Post - Virgil

    Sep 30, 25 01:03 PM

    *ADOPTED* DoB of Virgil: 2021 (4.5 years old) Reason for rehoming this big white fluffy: Owner has passed away and he is presently living in an apartment.

    Read More

  4. Gaston

    Sep 28, 25 05:49 PM

    Gaston *ADOPTED* This beauty went right into foster and was adopted soon after. DOB appox: 2020 (6-years-old) Location: Acton, ON Beautiful Gaston

    Read More

  5. Lola

    Sep 26, 25 06:44 PM

    A single family dwelling and a securely fenced yard of at least 5 feet are musts. DOB approx: Februay 12, 2021 Location: Acton, Ontario This is sweet

    Read More

  6. My dog Sam - 18-years-old

    Sep 26, 25 05:58 AM

    Just before his birthday
    Sam was rescued from a bad situation. His microchip showed his birthday was 2 months before my 2 year old son. They grew up together and he was the best

    Read More

  7. Pogo

    Sep 26, 25 05:51 AM

    Shenanigans on dad’s bed with Roxy!
    Pogo was a mix between a Great Pyrenees and a collie. Some people down south are trying to get dogs like him registered as a Great Collie. He was our gentle

    Read More

  8. Hardy

    Sep 15, 25 02:41 PM

    Hardy Location: Acton, ON DOB: Approx. January 2025 (we think he is older though) Single-family home required. Minimum 5-foot securely fenced yard.

    Read More